Showing posts with label insecticide. Show all posts
Showing posts with label insecticide. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

What's Cheap At Six Grand per Liter?

So, it seems that most dog owners dose their dogs with “spot-on” topical antiparasitics one a month to prevent fleas and ticks. It looks like I'll have to pick one for Scooter. There are a range of products to choose from, the popular brand names include Frontline, Advantage, and Advantix.

But, boy, are these things expensive!

Look at PetArmor, a generic for Frontline, and one of the cheapest options, in medium dog size. You get 3 doses; each dose is a tiny 1.34 ml plastic pipette, and the cost at Walmart is $25. That's $25 for about 4ml, or $6,250 per liter. OK, so maybe working out a cost per liter is not entirely fair, since it comes in three tiny plastic vials, but if you can get 1ml glass vials for $100/1000, or 10¢ each, online, these little plastic ones can't be all that expensive, so the ingredients must be super-expensive or something, right?

Mmmm… no. The basic Frontline (or PetArmor of Fiproguard) is a 9.8% solution of fipronil in, presumably, some kind of oil (fipronil is only very slightly soluble in water and the mechanism of action suggests a chemically inert edible oil, probably some kind of mineral oil like the stuff you buy in Ikea to rub into your wooden chopping boards at $10/liter or 1¢/ml). Fipronil itself can't be all that expensive, since you can get it in a 9.1% suspension (in water) for about $100/liter for termite control (Termidor SC or Taurus SC). Even if the entire cost of these products was solely in the fipronil, each vial would contain about 15¢ worth. So the material cost for 3 vials of these topical antiparasitics, including packaging, can't reasonably exceed $1, so why does it cost 25 to 60 times that? Inquiring minds want to know.